Is your credit insurance premium too high? How to test it, what to compare beyond price, and when switching broker or insurer makes sense.

The renewal terms arrive six weeks before the policy ends. The premium is up, or it is flat when you had hoped for a cut. You have not had a claim in years. Is it too high, and should you move?
Here is the short answer. You cannot tell from the premium alone. You can tell by testing it, and this is a good year to test. You have three options, in rising order of effort: renegotiate with your present insurer, move to a different insurer, or change the broker who does the asking. You can change broker without changing insurer, and you do not have to wait for renewal to do it. What you should not do is compare one number against another and pick the lower.
If you are new to the product, our plain-English guide to how credit insurance works explains how the premium is built.
Insurers are competing hard for business. In October, Insurance Business described the UK trade credit market as "unusually competitive", with cover widely available and prices softer. More insurers are chasing the same clients: Lloyd's direct credit premium grew by about a quarter in 2025 to around £1.6bn, and Atradius and Coface now both write business there. Across the wider London market, Lloyd's reported that rates fell 6.7% in the first half of 2026.
That will not last for ever. Atradius's UK claims were 8% higher in August than a year earlier. The Bank of England raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November. Allianz Trade expects about 25,600 UK insolvencies this year, still 21% above the average before the pandemic. When claims rise far enough, prices follow. A policyholder who tests the market now is doing so while insurers still want the business.
The premium is only one line. Before you compare anything, add up the whole cost of the year:
Take a hypothetical small supplier to the construction trade. This is an illustration, not a client. Its renewal premium is £12,000. Credit limit fees, charged for each customer the insurer approves, add about £3,000, so the year costs around £15,000. A fifth of the cost sits outside the headline number. Another insurer quotes £13,500 with its fees included. Against the premium it looks dearer. Against the full cost it is £1,500 cheaper. But it leaves out cover for binding contracts, which matters in construction. The cheaper price is only cheaper if you can live without that.
A cheaper policy that pays less is not cheaper. Put these side by side:
Often the best result is a better deal from the insurer you already have. Insurers price the clients they might lose more keenly than the ones they assume will stay. Ask for the rate, the fees and the terms to be reviewed against your record: no claims, good credit control, a spread of customers. A fixed rate for two years is worth asking for while prices are soft.
Sometimes another insurer simply wants your sector more, or takes a kinder view of your key customers. Moving is reasonable when the saving is real after fees, the limits on your main accounts are confirmed in writing before you commit, and the wording is at least as good.
At larger sizes the question changes. Take a hypothetical distributor with £120m of insured turnover and a renewal offer near £210,000. This is an illustration, not a client. A market test might put three options on the table. A lower rate, fixed for two years, with the same insurer. A different insurer at a lower price, but with tighter limits on two important customers. Or an excess of loss policy, which cuts the premium sharply and leaves the business to pay the first losses of the year itself. None is right for everyone. At that size the levers are structure and terms, and price follows from them.
Your broker is appointed by you, not by the insurer, and you can replace one at any time by signing a letter of authority. The policy stays where it is. The new broker takes over the handling, including limit appeals and claims. You normally pay nothing extra, because the broker is paid by commission from the insurer.
Changing makes sense if nobody has tested your premium for three years, if limit decisions go unchallenged, if claims are left to you, or if you only hear from your broker at renewal. Our guide to what to do when a limit is cut shows the work a broker should be doing between renewals.
One practical point. Do not ask several brokers to approach the same insurers at once. An insurer will usually deal with the first broker to submit your risk, and a crowded submission tends to get a worse answer. Choose one, and give them a clear run.
Switching is not always right, and it will not fix everything.
Rarely. A broker's commission is built into the price whether or not you use one, so cutting out the broker does not normally cut the premium. What you lose is someone to compare insurers, argue for limits and stand next to you in a claim.
Remember what the premium buys. We have read the administrators' reports for 528 recent UK administrations. The typical amount owed to unsecured creditors was about £900,000, and where the administrators gave an estimate, nearly nine in ten expected to pay those creditors nothing. The right question is whether the cover would pay, on your real customers, for a price that is fair.
You cannot judge a premium on its own. Add up the full cost, including limit fees. Compare the limits on your key customers, the share paid and the conditions, not just the price. Start three months before renewal. Renegotiate first, move insurer if the limits and wording hold up, and change broker if yours is not doing the work. Stay put if a claim or a troubled customer is in play. You can check how an insurer might see one of your customers with our free tools.
If your renewal is due in the next few months, send us the terms. We will tell you whether the price looks fair, what we would ask the insurer for, and whether it is worth moving at all. Sometimes the answer is to stay where you are. You can read more about how we arrange credit insurance.
This article is a general explanation. Every policy wording differs, so check yours.